Egg-cellent Adventures in French Toast: Delicious Alternatives and Foolproof Techniques
15 June 2025
Okay, let's talk French toast! It's not just a fancy breakfast; it's practically a historical monument on a plate, with roots stretching back to the Romans. And guess what? It's not even French, not entirely anyway! From the 'Poor Knights' in the UK to 'wentelteefjes' in the Netherlands (try saying that three times fast!), everyone has their own spin on this delicious dish.
But what if you're avoiding eggs? No problem! Whether you're vegan, have an allergy, or just fancy a change, there are plenty of fantastic egg substitutes for French toast that will still make your morning amazing. Get your creative chef's hat on, and let's dive into these options, with a little help from your new best friend, the Menuistia app.
Egg-Free French Toast: Your Delicious Options
1. Soy Milk: The Thick & Creamy Champion
Soy milk isn't just a drink; it's a fantastic egg replacement in baking too. Its thicker consistency compared to other plant-based milks makes it perfect for that luxurious soak that French toast needs. It brings the volume and works wonders in a 1:1 ratio, so it's easy to swap. Use butter for frying, and you're golden! Don't forget to explore the recipe customisation and menu planning features of Menuistia to explore healthy options.
2. Nutritional Yeast: The Cheesy Umami Boost
Yes, you heard it right! Nutritional yeast isn't just for popcorn. This deactivated yeast adds a cheesy, nutty, and slightly 'eggy' flavor that's brilliant in breakfast dishes. It's also packed with B12, which is great for your brain! It adds flavour and substance to your French toast batter and can be used in a variety of other dishes as well. Use the Menuistia app to track your B12 intake when planning your menus.
3. Custard Powder: The Smooth Operator
Mix custard powder with a little milk, heat it up, and boom! You've got an egg-free custard base that’s perfect for soaking your bread. Add a dash of vanilla and a pinch of salt for extra flavor. Make sure you work out the perfect measurements on the Menuistia app. You can use it to create and modify recipes, making the perfect French Toast every time.
4. Brioche & Challah: The Rich & Tender Alternatives
These breads are naturally dense and delicious and are great for French toast, whether you are using eggs or not. Brioche and challah bring a lovely texture and flavour, making them a superb base. They soak up the batter wonderfully. Let them sit for about 30 minutes for best results. The Menuistia app can even be used to track bread-making, just add the ingredients to a new custom recipe and you are ready to go!
5. Coconut Milk: The Tropical Twist
For a dairy-free option, canned coconut milk is fantastic! You'll need to thicken it a little with cornstarch or flour but it will give a subtle coconutty flavour. This one is definitely worth experimenting with if you are looking for a twist, remember, Menuistia can handle dairy and egg-free dietary options so you can tweak to your heart's content.
Why These Substitutes Work
Eggs work in French toast because their proteins bind the liquids, and add richness without masking flavours. Corn starch and other binders work well, but sometimes, the taste needs a boost. Nutritional yeast adds that perfect touch, and a little black salt can also do the trick for that 'eggy' flavour. All these substitutions can be easily tracked in the Menuistia app.
French Toast Tips & Tricks for Perfection!
- Stale Bread is Your Friend: Fresh bread tends to get soggy; a little staleness is ideal for soaking. It's why it's called 'lost bread' in French - using it up instead of throwing it away.
- Soak Time: Give your bread at least a couple of hours in the fridge to absorb the goodness (or even overnight!).
- Crunch is Key: Use breadcrumbs or shredded coconut to create a delightful crispy coating.
- Challah is a Winner: Thickly sliced challah brings that authentic French toast texture - crispy outside and soft inside.
- Stovetop + Oven: Get the best of both worlds by toasting on the stove and finishing in the oven.
- A Zest for Life: Add orange or lime zest for a flavour boost that will have everyone wondering 'what is it?!'
- Toppings Galore: Let your imagination go wild with mascarpone, brie, caramelized fruits, fresh berries... the options are endless! The Menuistia app can handle all of these.
Soggy French Toast Woes? No More!
Nobody likes soggy bread. For French toast perfection, it’s about the ratio (more 'eggy' than 'milky'), cooking at a medium-low heat (about 250 degrees), and just a quick dip on each side (no long soaks!). If you're using a substitute with no binding ability like just almond milk, use less, and add a little more cornstarch. The golden-brown crisp exterior means your French toast is cooked to perfection.
No Eggs? No Problem!
So, there you have it – delicious, egg-free French toast that's easy to create using the Menuistia app and these fantastic alternatives! It doesn't have to be a struggle, whether you're catering to allergies, dietary preferences, or just want to mix things up. Enjoy making your best French toast ever!